The rise of Islam Makhachev has brought an old debate back into focus, but this time it feels more serious than ever. For years, Khabib Nurmagomedov set the benchmark in lightweight MMA. Now, with Makhachev continuing to build his own run, the comparison is no longer avoidable.
There was a time when this conversation felt premature. It doesn’t anymore.
What Khabib’s legacy still represents
Khabib’s career is one of the cleanest in the sport. A 29-0 record, no real scares during his title run, and wins over some of the biggest names in the division. He didn’t just beat opponents, he controlled them from start to finish.
Fighters like Conor McGregor, Dustin Poirier, and Justin Gaethje came in with different styles and strengths, but the outcome looked familiar each time. Khabib imposed his game and never really let go.
What adds to that legacy is how he left. Still champion, still unbeaten, and without any visible decline. That kind of ending is rare, and it’s a big reason why his name still carries so much weight in these discussions.
Read More
Where Islam Makhachev stands right now
Islam Makhachev’s journey has followed a similar path in some ways, but it’s also taken its own direction. He established himself at lightweight, won the title, and defended it against top-level opposition. Those performances alone put him among the best of his era.
What stands out more, though, is how his game has developed. Early in his career, the focus was almost entirely on grappling. Now, he looks far more comfortable everywhere. He can strike when needed, manage distance better, and still fall back on his wrestling when the fight demands it.
There’s also a different kind of pressure on him. Carrying expectations tied to Khabib’s legacy isn’t easy, but he’s handled it without it becoming a distraction.
Has he gone past Khabib?
That’s where things get tricky. Khabib’s record is still untouched. There’s a certain finality to it, an unbeaten run that leaves no room for debate about dominance. That alone keeps him slightly ahead in most conversations.
At the same time, Islam Makhachev is still active and building. Every fight adds to his case. He’s facing elite competition, evolving his style, and staying at the top in a division that isn’t getting any easier.
Right now, it feels like Khabib still has the edge, but not by the margin he once did. Islam Makhachev has closed that gap, and if he keeps going the way he is, the conversation could shift sooner rather than later.
For now, it’s less about one clearly being ahead and more about two fighters linked by style and background, but carving out legacies that are starting to stand on their own.
Also Read: Tyson Fury: Beating Depression, Addiction, and the Best in the World
