Since Brendon McCullum’s appointment as coach in June 2022, the England Test team has undergone a radical reinvention. A fearless, fast-scoring batting philosophy and a new mindset of more bold, aggressive play have now branded the team as “Bazball.”Yet beneath the excitement, one inescapable fact persists: England continue to struggle against the two best Test nations, India and Australia.
England’s Blind Spot: Winning Against the Best
Despite the change in fortunes, England’s record against India and Australia remains a continuum of their struggles prior to Bazball. The team is yet to win an Ashes series since 2015, let alone a Test series against India since 2018-a drought that started well before the Stokes–McCullum era and continues to this day.
While the win rate for England against the other opponents in the WTC has risen considerably, the success rate against India and Australia remains at about half as good. They have drawn home series against both sides since June 2022 and lost 4-1 on their most recent tour of India.
Batting Reborn: Impressive Gains, But Not Against India and Australia
Strike Rates Up, Rankings Up.Yet a Ceiling Remains
No facet of the Bazball shift is more visible than England’s batting transformation. Their strike rate has leapt from 48.1 to 70.7, and their tally of centuries has doubled. In the pre-Bazball era, England ranked fifth or sixth among nine major Test teams for batting average and scoring rate; under McCullum, they sit at the very top.
Read More
These gains dissipate, however, when the opposition is India or Australia. Across both eras, the English batting unit has been statistically outperformed by those two dominant sides.
Bowling Improvements Except Against the Powerhouses
Meanwhile, England’s bowlers have also made marked progress, particularly on flat wickets that conventionally assist batsmen. The attack looks incisive against the other six WTC nations but the trend sharply reverses against India and Australia.
Of the 16 Tests played against these two sides since June 2022, England failed to take 20 wickets in six matches that include the rain-affected Old Trafford Test during the 2023 Ashes. This is a significant difference: England’s bowlers concede almost 10 more runs per wicket and take 15 more deliveries per dismissal against India and Australia than their numbers against other countries.
Since the start of the current WTC cycle in June 2023, England have the best balls-per-wicket ratio among all Test teams, 57.1, even better than Bangladesh’s 56.4.
Bazball’s Verdict: Revolutionary, Exciting But Still Waiting for a Defining Triumph The Stokes-McCullum method has undoubtedly rejuvenated English Test cricket.
It has generated energy, courage, and a surge of productivity against nearly all WTC rivals. But Bazball’s final test still awaits; for it to create an imperative legacy, England must have a landmark series win against either India or Australia ideally in the context of an unassailable Ashes triumph.
ALSO READ: Mitchell Starc Creates History In Ashes 2025-26 After Dismissing Joe Root
