Gautam Gambhir vs Greg Chappell: Comparing First 19 Matches As Coach

Advertisement

Greg Chappell, once admired in India for his cricketing prowess, saw his reputation decline during his controversial coaching stint with the national team in the 2000s. Years later, Gautam Gambhir, India’s current head coach, is facing similar scrutiny as fans draw comparisons between the two.

Advertisement

The question arises: Is Gambhir following in Chappell’s footsteps, or is there more to the story? Let’s break down both coaches’ performances in their first 19 matches with Team India.

Gambhir’s First 19 Matches: A Rocky Start

Gambhir took over the role after Rahul Dravid’s successful ICC T20 World Cup 2024 campaign. His coaching debut started strong with a 3-0 T20I series win against Sri Lanka. However, the momentum didn’t last long.

India suffered a surprising 0-2 ODI series loss against Sri Lanka, causing initial doubts about his leadership. This was followed by a strong comeback with back-to-back whitewashes against Bangladesh in both Tests and T20Is.

The real challenge came during the home series against New Zealand, where India suffered a shocking Test series loss. It marked India’s first home Test series defeat since 2012 and their first whitewash at home since 2000.

The downward spiral continued with a crushing 1-3 Test series defeat against Australia. The team’s poor Test form under Gambhir has raised serious concerns despite occasional T20 successes.

Chappell’s First 19 Matches: Mixed Results with Off-Field Drama

Chappell’s coaching tenure started with promise but was soon overshadowed by controversy. His initial series was a tri-nation ODI tournament in Sri Lanka, where India finished runners-up after losing to the hosts in the final.

This was followed by another tri-series in Zimbabwe, where India again reached the final but lost to New Zealand. However, Chappell’s India secured a 2-0 Test series win against Zimbabwe and a commanding 6-1 home ODI series victory over Sri Lanka.

Despite decent on-field results, his off-field clashes with captain Sourav Ganguly made headlines. The tension escalated during the Zimbabwe tour, with Chappell openly suggesting Ganguly should be dropped due to poor form. Ganguly eventually left the tour mid-way, and Rahul Dravid replaced him as captain.

Performance Comparison After 19 Matches

Stat Breakdown:

Key Takeaways:

• Test Success: Chappell had a 100% win rate in Tests after 19 matches, compared to Gambhir’s 30%.
• ODI Consistency: Chappell’s ODI record was significantly better (65% win rate) than Gambhir’s (0%).
• T20 Edge: Gambhir has excelled in T20s, winning all six games, a format that was rare during Chappell’s tenure.

Beyond the Numbers: The Impact of Leadership Style

While Chappell’s statistical performance appears superior, his leadership was marred by public disputes with players, especially Ganguly. Gambhir, on the other hand, has faced criticism for player relationships, particularly after India’s poor Test run.

However, Gambhir has shown great tactical skills in the shorter formats, evidenced by his role in guiding Kolkata Knight Riders to an IPL title in 2024.

Extra Insights for a Better Perspective

• Evolving Formats: T20 cricket was not a major focus during Chappell’s time, making direct comparisons slightly skewed.
• Player Relations: Strong coaching involves both results and team harmony—an area where both struggled.
• Pressure Management: India’s cricketing culture involves immense scrutiny, which both coaches have felt during their initial tenures.

Final Verdict: Who Fared Better?

While both coaches faced turbulence early on, Chappell’s initial record was stronger statistically. However, Gambhir’s T20 success and potential for recovery in Tests keep his journey open for redemption. His next few series will be crucial in defining whether he can break free from the shadow of Chappell’s controversial legacy.

Also Read: Exploring, Experimenting, And Delivering Value: Following His Ikigai, Eman Pulis, The Force Behind SiGMA

Advertisement